MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Petzvals... Plus One!
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

I have quite a large collection of cinema projection lenses and by far the most common design is the Petzval.

Early lenses are usually the classic 4:3 design with a cemented achromat at the front and an air-spaced pair at the rear, later lenses can use a 4:2 design with two cemented doublets, presumably to increase transmission.

Occasionally the rear group is flipped, a modification introduced by Dallmeyer, but the 4:3 and 4:2 designs account for all of these variations...

almost.

I have found a very few Petzvals with an extra element added to the rear. These lenses are Ross Super-Rosskotes (every one I have seen), and a very few early Benoist Berthiot Cinestars.

I am unsure of what the desired effect of adding the fifth element was, bearing in mind that with projection lenses light throughput is paramount, and adding more glass will decrease this.

I have seen suggestions online that it was intended to reduce field curvature, Petzvals are the Poster Children for this, so it would be understandable. A problem with is idea is that the fifth element would have to be negative to flatten the field, and in both the designs I have seen, it is positive.

The Cinestars actually do have an unusually flat field, but my Rosskotes are all totally Banana Town, so it is 50-50 empirically, on the extra glass being intended as a flattener.

There must be some effect on the bokeh though, as a while ago I was searching through my collection for lenses that gave the "Cooke" look in their bokeh, and the Ross and Cinestar 5:3 lenses came out top of the testing.

I have recently got another one of these strange 5:3 lenses, and as they are quite rare and unusual, I thought I would post a piece here about its adaptation and characteristics.

The Lens




This is a Ross Super "Rosskote" 4.5" (114mm) projection lens, it would have been used in cinemas to project 35mm movie film. The aperture is not stated, but measurement of the exposed front element suggests f2.1.

The lens is all-brass construction, the front section is painted and the rear tube is nickel plated. The lens is very sturdily built, with thick walls, honestly, you could probably hammer nails in with it. This very robust construction means that the lens is quite weighty at 930g, it is 5.25" (140mm) long.

As with all Super Rosskotes I have seen, the front 5/8" of the lens is externally threaded to allow the attachment of an anamorphic adaptor or size adaptor.

Another feature I have seen on all Rosskotes is a small brass screw inserted into the collar of the larger front section.



The purpose of this screw is a mystery to me, the threaded hole penetrates to the tube interior and the screw fills this, being flush internally. There is only one hole and it is so small it is unlikely to be a mounting location.

I would love to know why this feature was included.

The Optics.

As mentioned above, this lens has a 5:3 design.



Measured optical diagram of my lens.

The front two groups are a usual Petzval arrangement, although not classical, as the rear group is cemented and flipped compared to Petzval's original design; the extra fifth element is positive with a plano outer face.



The lens is coated, probably a single MgF2 layer and this was in good condition in my lens. As the name specifically denotes coating (Rosskote), the lens was probably made not long after WW2.

Many of the Rosskote lenses I have obtained have had a milky disc, or annulus in the cement layer of one of the doublets. This is caused by heat from the arc degrading the cement, repairing this is difficult as the lens uses synthetic cement which is ironically hard to separate.

Luckily, this particular lens is free from the problem.

Adapting.



The lens has a projection standard 52.5mm rear tube and clamping rings are easily available for this. I used an M65 ring and helicoid, followed by an M42 reducer and E-mount adaptor (I use Sony bodies).

Rear focus at infinity is 45mm, so there is plenty room to fit extension tubes to give finger relief.

Internally, all of the elements have very good edge blackening. The interior is also blackened, but I improved this considerably by painting with Black 4.0.

The design uses completely internal retaining rings and a very weird long tube to hold the rear elements in place. Access is by unscrewing the front section and collar from the rear tube.

Another odd addition was rubber sealing rings on both of the external elements (visible in element photo). I have seen these used in some US lenses, but they are very rare in UK designs.

Handling.

The lens is heavy and most of its weight is in the front section, so when mounted it is no surprise that the rig is very front heavy. This is actually not too bad in use, and the forward weight distribution does not seem to compromise IBIS the way some longer Kalee lenses can.

Example Image Parameters

I shoot stereograms as standard, the pairs posted here are for cross-eyed viewing. If you cannot freeview these in stereo (some folk are unable), simply use a single pane to assess IQ, bokeh, and etc..

All example images are full frame and unsharpened, I have corrected for vignetting and CA, but there has been no purple, or coloured fringing reduction in post.

Contrast has been helped in post, most vintage taking lenses require help in this area, and projection glass like this generally needs even more.

All frames shot RAW with Sony A7rII bodies.

It was very windy here when I took these shots, so motion blur will have affected the leaf pics to some extent.

The IQ.

This is a sharp lens.

The sharp zone with plane subjects is limited as the lens has strong field curvature, but the lens gives sharp results right into the frame corners when specifically focused there.


Pixel level crop of one of the images below. Note sharply imaged spiderweb and wafer thin DOF. Also notice intense purple fringing on some of the leaves.

Focus is decisive with no spread, showing very good SA correction.

Contrast was good as received, and very good after internal painting with Black 4.0, no doubt aided by the coating.

Focus peaking functioned very well.

The image circle at infinity is only 55mm, so soft vignetting is apparent on FF although this is easy to fix in post. Given the restricted coverage, this will probably not be a useful lens for GFX bods.

The lens shows purple fringing on very high contrast edges, although intense, this is small in dimensions and easy to correct in post.

With correctly focused subjects there is no coloured fringing on edges and no "glow". The depth of field for near subjects is tiny, so green/purple edges due to LOCA can be seen outside of the sharp zone.

The Bokeh.

This is soft bokeh lens.



Bokeh bubbles are large and generally soft edged, but in this case they are very dependent on the size of the source producing them. So it is possible to have soft, almost melted edge bubbles from largish sources in the same shot as bubbles with very defined edges from more pinpoint origins.

Having said that, the "defined edge" bubble are just that, sharp edged, there is no strong outlining such as that produced by certain triplets, like the Trioplan.

As to be expected, sharp edged bubbles can show some stacking when overlapped, but this is mild, the general trend is toward total merging into blur.

All types of bubbles show catseyeing, but this is only at the frame extremes, there is no substantial catseyeing visible across the short axis of the frame at all.

There is almost no bokeh patterning or texturing, it is usually just a smooth blur. Even with highly detailed, repetitive OOF backgrounds, the lens strongly resists edge emphasis or pattern pick up



In the café "Open" shot above, the lens has smooth blurred all of the interior high contrast sharp edges. Note how only the small sources such as LEDs produce sharp edged bokeh bubbles, whilst the main lighting gives only soft blobs.



In the "copper lightshade" image above the background was stacked screens with wire grids. The lens has muted the periodicity of the wire grid and rendered this almost like vertically flowing water. I have projection lenses that would pick up periodicity like this, even when mostly covered with foliage, and reproduce it as a strong moiré grid pattern in the bokeh.



In the "tree avenue" shot above note the variety of sharp and soft edged bokeh balls produced by the light coming through the trees.





The backgrounds in the leaf shots were just a few metres behind the subject, but the lens has soft-blurred them into unrecognizability.

The Bottom Line.

Pros.

The lens is sharp, and that sharpness is useable over the whole frame, it has good contrast in its native state and with a little effort this can be improved to excellent.

The bokeh is predominantly of the smooth type that seems to be the most sought after these days, and there is a lot of it.

The fast aperture and field curvature make for excellent subject isolation.

Cons.

The lens is heavy and dense, and most of the weight is forward, this can give an odd feel to users not used to adapting.

The Rosskotes are very prone to cement degradation and the synthetic cement used makes the doublets very difficult to separate for a repair.

In contrast to Dallmeyer and Taylor Hobson lenses the Rosskotes were not sought after, and that was reflected in the pricing, a few years ago Ross's could frequently be bought for £30 or under. This has changed and now they often bring £100 or more, so they are not the bargain that they once were.

That said, they are some of the sharpest projection lenses available and have almost none of the optical faults that plague other brands, if anything, the recent price increase has merely brought them into line with these.

If you do fancy one, beware of the cement damage, it is almost impossible to spot in Ebay photos and it is very common, I have had to recement two of my Super-Rosskotes, in one case, both of the doublets.

Despite the drawbacks, it can do this:-



Reply

Excellent overviev, great insights into an - as far as I'm aware - almost completely undocumented Petzval variant, and wonderful shots as well! Thanks a lot for sharing. If I stumble upon some information about similar designs, I'll make sure to share it here as well. Seems like another thing worth documenting.