MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Leica Q
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

It's hot topic most places. Thoughts?


Reply

Typical Leica - overpriced and under-specced.

24mp FF with a 1.7/28 lens in a compact body sounds good, but the damn thing is 3,000ukp.

Sony's RX1 has a 24mp FF sensor and a Zeiss 2/35 lens and costs 1,300ukp.

Hard to justify paying 2.5x the price for the red dot. The RX1 matches the Q for IQ, is smaller, 200g lighter, only thing it lacks is touchscreen (which I hate) and an EVF.

Another big downside is the size of the lens on the Q, it's simply massive and means that it doesn't fit into the compact bracket, despite the size of the body.

Samsung's new BSI 28mp APS-C sensor outperforms the Sony 24mp FF sensor so let's hope we see this sensor in a compact body. The NX500 can be had for 400ukp with the 16-50 lens. Sadly, the lens options for NX are limited, but the Samsung 2/30 lens is excellent and costs about 200ukp. So you can get close to the Q's IQ for a fifth of it's price and in a smaller and lighter package that is much more capable in other areas, such as 4K video.

So what is the Q? It's a lot of money for a niche item. The 1.7/28 Summilux might be an impressive piece of glass, but very few people could justify the price tag.


Editado por última vez por iangreenhalgh1 el Vie Jun 19, 2015 7:03 am; editado 2 veces en total


Reply

I think 99.97% people here won't spend over 4k buying this camera.


Reply

Still there would be no harm in talking about it surely? The price bracket of the camera would make all the difference for most of us.

Uhoh would you consider buying it at all?


Reply

More than happy to talk about it!

A large sensor prime lens compact is something I am fond of. For a long time, the only one was the Ricoh GR series which used a fairly small 1/1.7" sensor, then Fuji introduced the X10 and X100 which used a 12mp 2/3" sensor and a 12mp APS-C sensor, respectively. Today there are a few more options from other makers, Ricoh did a 12mp APS-C module for the GXR with a fixed f2.5 prime, Sony has both 1" and full frame compacts and Canon released a G series with a 1" sensor.

Myself, I bought a Fuji XF-1 secondhand for 30ukp. It has a 12mp 2/3" sensor and a manual zoom lens that is an f1.8/25 at the wide end. I'm impressed by the IQ, the lens is very sharp even at f1.8 and the DR and noise are very good for a smallish sensor. However, I'd definitely prefer a higher-end compact with a bigger sensor and a prime lens. I'm watching the prices of secondhand models closely.

Given the way Leica cameras hold their value then I doubt the Q will ever be an option for me though, so regardless of how good it might be, it's off my list.

I also have a Pentax Q7, this has a 1/1.7" sensor and I use it with Fujinon c-mount lenses. It's a tiny camera, I bought it to fit in a coat pocket as a take everywhere camera and it does that job well. IQ isn't up there with an APS-C camera but it's more than good enough for most uses. This sensor is BSI and is much better than older non-BSI sensor of the same size, so it's clear that sensor technology is improving rapidly and impressive IQ can be had with smaller sensors but FF still holds a certain allure.

A couple of Q7 shots:





Reply

I'm a Leica-fan. You know that.
But I am not a blind Leica fanatic. And I often dare to criticize the company's decisions.
I did so when they marketed the "X". And I do so now.

The "Q" is a very good camera, with a fantastic sensor and an amazing lens.

But would I spend so much money on such a "restricted" camera? Never!

C'mon, a 1.7/28? That's a lens for a very special kind of photography. (I do have a 1.8/28 for my Nikon Df and sometimes that's exactly what I want, but perhaps in 5% of all the photographic situations I am shooting in.)

For the same money, I could get a Sony A7 II with a very nice 24 and an excellent 50mm lens and a decent 90mm - which as a set would make much more sense.

But what do I know? I am sure that Leica could sell more "Q"-cams than they can produce.


Reply

theyve been truly muddling about, throwing all manner of non rf stuff on the proverbial wall to see what will stick: the T, i T-hink not; xvario, if it were any slower itd be goin' backwards; 35mm fixed lens X models, no vf--end of story for many.

to me, with its new sensor, low light ability, state of the art vf, and fast reliable FF af, the Q might finally and actually be something upon which they can build. either different fixed FLs or an interchangeable model, or both. but theyll probably muck that up too.


Reply

When I first saw the Q and read several first impressions, Ming's and Huffs and DPR's, I was like whoa: it's a 28 cron on a small light body.

No it is not. The Q 28mm lens has around 10% native distortion, which is attacked before the RAW or JPEGs come out of the camera by the Fujitsu proceesseor on camera, which is set to "M9 Emulation" mode. But they say simple barrel distortion is the easiest to fix with least quality loss, and the images from the Q are impressive to many real photographers. The camera is selling. It is not in the league of the M9 and 28 cron. In my opinion that is the best 28mm setup in the world today.

The EVF on the Q is the best ever seen on a camera, period. But quite a margin. Not only is it higher resolution than the Sonys, but it's much brighter (wider aperture), so there is alot less noise in the MAG. But you can't move the MAG box.

Anyway this is a big news camera. Much more so than the X etc. What it really is, that's not yet clear. But it's interesting.

As to the price: the general feeling: cheaper than expected by at least a grand.

It's of special interest to me because 28 is my fav FL.


Reply

Cheaper by a grand than expected?

Leicists must be very masochistic....

I wouldn't be so sure about that EVF, Fuji's X-T1 has the most advanced EVF yet designed:

http://fujifilm-x.com/development_story/en/developer/evf/

I guess whether it's worth the price is down to the IQ. Leica released 35 official sample images:

http://www.photographyblog.com/previews/leica_q_official_photos/

Yes, the IQ is impressive, but bottom line: if the IQ isn't clearly better than the competition then it's nothing more than an overpriced luxury item.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 escribió:
Cheaper by a grand than expected?

Leicists must be very masochistic....

I wouldn't be so sure about that EVF, Fuji's X-T1 has the most advanced EVF yet designed:

http://fujifilm-x.com/development_story/en/developer/evf/

I guess whether it's worth the price is down to the IQ. Leica released 35 official sample images:

http://www.photographyblog.com/previews/leica_q_official_photos/

Yes, the IQ is impressive, but bottom line: if the IQ isn't clearly better than the competition then it's nothing more than an overpriced luxury item.


They may have the same finder as there is a fujitsu processor in the Camera. 4K is rich for my blood, but not for many, and it's about the cost of a very good mountain bike today. Where the Q really kills the Sony is handling, with great interface, smooth feel on the MF etc.

While it's bigger than the Sony RX1, it is the lightest digital FF 28 rig in the world today.

But for this sort of thing, the Rioch GR 18 is meant to be superb, for 500 or so.


Reply

I too, like 28mm and I expect the 1.7/28 on the Q is one of the very best. I wonder what the top 28s actually are today? I can't think of many, Samsung do a 2/30 for the NX, Sigma do a 1.9/30 for M4/3 and NEX, Fuji do a 2.8/27 for the X-series, there's a Zeiss ZM 28mm, I'm struggling to think of others.

I like the idea of manual focussing as well as AF, that's a good move.

There really isn't an equivalent to the Q available yet, the RX100 is the closest (24mp FF, 2/35) so I really do get the appeal of it.

I really love my FF a850, and I use the 28mm Minolta AF on it a lot, but it's hardly a thing for the pocket.

I'll take a look at that Ricoh GR18, not seen that one yet; I keep looking at secondhand Fuji X-pro1s as a pocket camera as it has a good APS-C sensor, a good EVF/OVF and there are some excellent small primes for it.

My hope is that the Q prompts other manufacturers to make larger sensor compacts, however the trend seems to be towards smaller ones like the 1" Canon used and is used by Nikon in the CX cameras and Samsung in the NX Mini. They are cramming 20mp onto a 1" sensor, which to me, is a bad thing, less mp please on these smaller sensors so we get better DR and noise performance.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 escribió:
I too, like 28mm and I expect the 1.7/28 on the Q is one of the very best. I wonder what the top 28s actually are today? I can't think of many, Samsung do a 2/30 for the NX, Sigma do a 1.9/30 for M4/3 and NEX, Fuji do a 2.8/27 for the X-series, there's a Zeiss ZM 28mm, I'm struggling to think of others.


You cannot really compare those lenses since some are made for APS or µ4/3, others for format 135.

If we like to find competitors for the 1.7/28 of the Q, we need to look at a Leica Summicron 2/28, a Nikkor 1.8/28 (both really expensive) or a Sigma EX 1.8/28 (rather affordable) etc.

The problem is that we cannot use the Q-lens on any other camera to check how much is genuine lens performance and how much is "algorithm".


Reply

BTW, this is what Erwin Puts says about it:

http://www.imx.nl/photo/blog/files/6031d90a117e7cc00f78f9ee29a41ca9-8.html


Reply

LucisPictor escribió:
iangreenhalgh1 escribió:
I too, like 28mm and I expect the 1.7/28 on the Q is one of the very best. I wonder what the top 28s actually are today? I can't think of many, Samsung do a 2/30 for the NX, Sigma do a 1.9/30 for M4/3 and NEX, Fuji do a 2.8/27 for the X-series, there's a Zeiss ZM 28mm, I'm struggling to think of others.


You cannot really compare those lenses since some are made for APS or µ4/3, others for format 135.

If we like to find competitors for the 1.7/28 of the Q, we need to look at a Leica Summicron 2/28, a Nikkor 1.8/28 (both really expensive) or a Sigma EX 1.8/28 (rather affordable) etc.

The problem is that we cannot use the Q-lens on any other camera to check how much is genuine lens performance and how much is "algorithm".


I know, they are all APS-C lenses apart from the Zeiss, so hard to compare directly.

28mm lenses for FF are a bit thin on the ground these days. I don't know how good the EX version is, but I used to have a Sigma 1.8/28 Aspherical and it really was nothing special. It was for Canon EOS so could only use it on film, old Sigmas don't work on modern Canon bodies.


Reply

LucisPictor escribió:
BTW, this is what Erwin Puts says about it:

http://www.imx.nl/photo/blog/files/6031d90a117e7cc00f78f9ee29a41ca9-8.html


Puts is very grumpy about the camera, which I find pretty entertaining.

Lucas, I might even consider the Q if it just had a 28 cron on there and shot it like the M9, because, like Ian, I love the 28.

BTW the Rioch GR is 18.x mm on an APS-C f/2.8 so it's a true 28 FOV. Ming raves and raves about it. He claims it's right with the 28 cron, though of course it's alot slower when you factor in both the stop and the sensor.

The funny thing is today is the golden age of 28mm Smile Why? iPhone 6 is 29.8mm effective. LOL

As many here know there are a bunch of decent SLR 28s, with that tokina 28/2 being the best deal I think.

For small ones: hex 28, rokkor 28, CV 28s (there are three) Older LTM 28s, 5 versions of the Leica 28 Elmarit, all totally different. The latest is very small and pretty good. V4 is probably the best technical version. ZM 28 is good, but not at the level of their 35s.

But the real top predators are the new 28 Summilux, which is about 7k, and meant to be incredible. I have seen quite a few samples and it's the only one which I think competes with the great 28 Summicron.

But the summicron prefers the M9 to the M240, funny enough. Too sharp I hear form 240 guys LOL


Reply

I've been playing with a Fuji XF1 I bought secondhand cheap. It has a 12mp 2/3" sensor and a 1.7-4.9 25-100mm (equiv) lens.

It's impressing me a lot as there is no distortion or CA (I bet there is some software correction going on) and no noise at all upto ISO 800, impressive what Fuji have done with a 2/3" sensor. The x10 uses the same sensor.

As a wide angle shooter, the lens on this camera suits me great, it's really sharp and contrasty.



All that said, I do want an APS-C compact still, preferably with a prime lens around 28mm equiv. which is what the Fuji x100 is - 12mp APS-C Xtrans sensor and a wide angle prime. of course, it won't match the IQ of the Leica Q but it's around 10% of the price.

Thinking about it, allowing oneself to dream and ignore financial constraints, then what would be the ultimate in camera/lens combo that would fit the somewhat compact and 28mm prime requirements. I guess that's when the Q comes into it's own as the other option is an M body with a 28mm lens. Maybe that's what the Q should be compared with and in that light, the price doesn't look so silly.

For a poor person like me however, perhaps a secondhand Fuji X-Pro1 with the superb 27mm Fujinon pancake would be the best solution?

What about legacy 28mm options? I'm not clued up on what small RF 28mms are available. The one I've always wanted is the Contax G Biogon 2.8/28, but being a Biogon, it doesn't play well on digital sensors. That said, i don't know if there is a MILC camera it does work well on, if there is, that becomes an interesting option I think.


Reply

uhoh7 escribió:

BTW the Ricoh GR is 18.x mm on an APS-C f/2.8 so it's a true 28 FOV. Ming raves and raves about it. He claims it's right with the 28 cron, though of course it's alot slower when you factor in both the stop and the sensor.


Well, Ricoh released recently the improved version GR II with the same 18.3 mm lens (28mm FOV). Ricoh started some 20 years ago with the GR concept (28mm fix focus) already on film. I must admit that 28mm was never my most favorite focus length. However, I've taken the GR Lens A12 28mm/F2.5 (actual 18.3mm on APSC) for my Ricoh GXR with me on my last excursion and finally used no other module on the camera. Wink
It turned out to be a very capable combination and delivered really excellent image quality. Most probably comparable to the GR/GR II camera with 16MP APSC sensor. At least it is the same lens. Maybe I will use it more often in future.
It's somehow funny that Leitz more or less copied now the GR concept from Ricoh with their new Leica Q. Maybe a revenge for the GXR Mount? I don't know. I think if somebody can live without the red dot on a camera the Ricoh GR is the better option.