MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Pentax Q or Nikon 1 for extreme telephoto
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

A thought came that due to the silly crop factor of Pentax Q (5.6), can it be used as an extreme telephoto lens for subjects such as birds or astronomy. I have since found some examples on other forums (with varying degrees of success), but has anyone here any experience with this? And if so, which lenses work better?


Reply

Here's my attempt on birding with the Q + Tair 11A 135/4 (roughly around 745mm 35mm equiv.):



I would say for birding with MF lenses on Q, it's not undoable, but the Nikon 1 system is superior to the Q system in pretty much all aspects except the crop factor, size & weight, and maybe the in body image stabilization (but I guess you'll hardly notice any difference when you're shooting at 500mm+ focal length 35mm equiv.):

1. Even the official Q to Pentax PKA Adapter does not provide AF as opposed to the Nikon FT1, which makes shooting moving objects such as birds a lot easier than the Q to PKA adapter. The FT1 supports many Nikon mount lenses with VR/VC/OS you can take a look at samples with the Nikon 1 + FT1 + Sigma 50-500mm combo, the results are quite stunning.
2. No EVF available as opposed to Nikon V1, V2, and V3, making it quite difficult to nail focus relying only on the small LCD screen especially under bright sunlight. You might be better off getting a LCD viewfinder loup for clearer view.
3. The 1 inch sensor is generally superior in IQ and noise performance compared to 1/2.3 and 1/1.7 inch sensors.
4. The Nikon 1 series is generally faster in startup, continuous shooting, and overall reaction speed compared to the Q.
5. The Q system's 06 15-45/2.8 is an excellent telephoto lens imo, but for birding, is still inferior to the Nikon 1 70-300mm for birds.

In terms of astro-photography that's a different story, I have never tried it with the Q, but have heard people using it to shoot the moon with some success. Still would probably better off doing more research on this before deciding.

Hope this helps. Very Happy


Reply

Hey bruzzo, thanks for such a detailed and helpful reply. so I guess Nikon would be more helpful for birding. i guess the AF capability coupled with the VF alone is worth considering. I try to get rid of some existing gear before jumping into a new system!