MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Canon Eos 5D mk1 exposure variation with MF lenses
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

Dear All
did someone find a final solution to the problem of the exposure variation of this camera (and all other Canon Eos I was told) with manual focus lenses?
I have various Leica R and if I use it with an adapter on my 5D the exposure is read correctly only at full aperture. Closing the diaphragm the pictures becomes over-exposed.
Would I get the same problem with modern MF lenses like Samyang or Zeiss?
Thank you for your help.
Bye
Luca


Reply

Welcome Luca!


Reply

thank you! No answer at all? Nobody uses Canon bodies with MF lenses?


Reply

Luca,

I do, but it is another beast, the MarkII, and actually i use a handheld meter, a old Gossen Lunasix - tired of trial & error correcting exposure "TTL",

[]s,

Renato


Reply

I am using my manual 35mm and MF lenses from fisheye until long telephoto lenses, with adapters, successfully on my 5DMkII body. Especially, for my important 15mm and 18mm SWA Distagon's, I've got the camera mirror shortend. All lenses work fine, and I am not using any AF glasses on my 5DMkII at all. I don't need autofocus, because my eyes are still fine!


Reply

Dear Opal
so with 5D Mk2 you do not have exposure problems? very strange.. I was told that all EOS digital bodies had this problem of not constant exposure readings closing the diaphragm.
Perhaps your lenses have a factory installed chip that corrects every problem.
I am using Leica R lenses with an adaptor with old chip to help focusing.

Dear RSalles
unfortunately a separate meter is too slow in using for me...

Thank you
Luca

PS: why I setted my profile preferences as "Always notify me of replies: Sends an e-mail when someone replies to a topic you have posted in. This can be changed whenever you post." and this topic also shows flagged the notify box but I do not receive any email alertin for new replies? Are there some bugs in this web site?


Reply

Welcome to the forum, Luca.

From your question, I am not clear whether you are saying,
(i) you are using two different f2.8 lens, and the camera is giving you different readings for let say f2.8 or
(ii) Meter is out when you stop down to, let say f8 but is correct at let say f2.8?

If it is stop down metering problem, I think this is not limited to 5D or Canon. This is one of 'side effect' if I can call it this way when using old manual lens on modern DSLR via adapter. Can't remember where I read but something like metering is good till maybe f5.6 or f6.3. after which you will need to do some compensation on the value the camera gives you.


Reply

Welcome Luca!

LuPi escribió:
adaptor with old chip


With newer chip (Dandelion), wheel is used to set aperture on camera, the camera meters for that aperture with lens wide open, then close aperture to make photo -- exposure is accurate.

LuPi escribió:
PS: why I setted my profile preferences as "Always notify me of replies: Sends an e-mail when someone replies to a topic you have posted in. This can be changed whenever you post." and this topic also shows flagged the notify box but I do not receive any email alertin for new replies? Are there some bugs in this web site?


Not a bug, however, the site notify email function is sometimes disabled (for everybody), but those do get queued & sent when notify function is re-enabled again.


Reply

my_photography escribió:
Welcome to the forum, Luca.
From your question, I am not clear whether you are saying,
(i) you are using two different f2.8 lens, and the camera is giving you different readings for let say f2.8 or
(ii) Meter is out when you stop down to, let say f8 but is correct at let say f2.8?


confirmed option 2
I have different lenses (leica R) with different maximum apertures. If I shot in the same conditions in AV mode closing the diaphgragm the exposure value is not the same, usually the pictures get overexposed


Reply

visualopsins escribió:

With newer chip (Dandelion), wheel is used to set aperture on camera, the camera meters for that aperture with lens wide open, then close aperture to make photo -- exposure is accurate.


so with an adapter with the new chip I can memorize the aperture of the lens and shot without any problem in stop down AV mode getting good exposure?

visualopsins escribió:

Not a bug, however, the site notify email function is sometimes disabled (for everybody), but those do get queued & sent when notify function is re-enabled again.


since my first post in this topic I never received an email alert. Very strange and very uncomfortable

regards
Luca


Reply

LuPi escribió:
visualopsins escribió:

With newer chip (Dandelion), wheel is used to set aperture on camera, the camera meters for that aperture with lens wide open, then close aperture to make photo -- exposure is accurate.


so with an adapter with the new chip I can memorize the aperture of the lens and shot without any problem in stop down AV mode getting good exposure?


I use the Manual mode...the meter makes mistakes. Wink

In Av mode, set aperture on camera with wheel, half-press shutter to meter, 'lock' AE, stop lens, press shutter.


Reply

visualopsins escribió:
LuPi escribió:
visualopsins escribió:

With newer chip (Dandelion), wheel is used to set aperture on camera, the camera meters for that aperture with lens wide open, then close aperture to make photo -- exposure is accurate.


so with an adapter with the new chip I can memorize the aperture of the lens and shot without any problem in stop down AV mode getting good exposure?


I use the Manual mode...the meter makes mistakes. Wink

In Av mode, set aperture on camera with wheel, half-press shutter to meter, 'lock' AE, stop lens, press shutter.


With my old adaptor the aperture shown in the display is f/2 and I cannot move it.
Do you confirm that with Dandelion chip other that memorizing the maximum aperture of each lens I can simulate setting different apertures? So the meter will read correctly wide open but I can simulate closing the diaphragm and then report it manually on the lens.
The only thing that cannot work is with flash in TTL mode. Am I correct? With TTL flash there is no way to have a correct exposure with close diaphragm.
regards
Luca


Reply

LuPi escribió:
With my old adaptor the aperture shown in the display is f/2 and I cannot move it.
Do you confirm that with Dandelion chip other that memorizing the maximum aperture of each lens I can simulate setting different apertures? So the meter will read correctly wide open but I can simulate closing the diaphragm and then report it manually on the lens.
The only thing that cannot work is with flash in TTL mode. Am I correct? With TTL flash there is no way to have a correct exposure with close diaphragm.
regards
Luca


Yes, chip "memorizes" maximum aperture (and focal length), then wheel on camera is used to set aperture # on camera -- the aperture # set on camera is recorded in EXIF (and focal length).

EMF user manual ver3.0

Haz clic aquí para verlo en eBay


Reply

So I am wondering how can work on Canon bodies the new wide aperture low price lenses Samyang. From the pictures I see on the net they have no chip at all.

Concerning flash there is no solution?

regards
Luca

PS: I continue not receiving at all any kind of email notification for the post of this forum even if all the option are enabled