MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Ilford FP4+ in Kodak Microdol-X, Micro-Nikkor 3.5/55
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

I've grown to really love FP4/FP4+ developed in 1:3 Microdol-X, such great tonality and the grain and sharpness are very good for this film. I've also grown to really love this Micro-Nikkor.

#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6

#7

#8

#9

#10

#11


Reply

Indeed, great work!! I love them all.


Reply

last one for me.....


Reply

Cheers. I was cursing myself for not taking a longer lens as those boats on the still water with the sun really low in the sky would have made a great shot. The mud on the flats is too soft to walk on to get close enough with the Nikkor 3.5/55, I learnt that one the hard way last year. Wink


Reply

The 10th and 11th shots are really well done. The boat is my favorite of the series.


Reply

#10 and #11 are very nice, you have a spectacular seaside.


Reply

Thanks guys. The view from where 10 and 11 was shot is breathtaking, you can see most of the mountains in the Cumbrian range.

It isn't a very pretty spot to be honest, it's the former site of Millom Ironworks and it's just rubble, slag and a few remaining bits of rusting metal.


Reply

Hey Ian, that HP4 seems to have a very good tonality range. What did you scan the negatives with?

I wonder if I might pick your brain for a moment --

The only ISO 125 b&w film I've ever used has been Kodak Plus X, which I've always liked, but it's been discontinued for a while now and is getting hard to find. Just looking at your photos, the Ilford HP4 looks to compare well in terms of sharpness and grain. So, I reckon I need to give this stuff a try.

I'm wondering, have you ever developed HP4 using D-76? I've never used Microdol X before but I've used D-76 with Tri-X and Plus X both and it works well.


Reply

Hi Michael.

Just to be clear FP4 is 125 ISO, HP5 is 400, I mix them up all the time. Smile

I never used Plus-X so I can't compare it to FP4.

Microdol-X diluted 1:3 behaves pretty similar to D76.

Here are some FP4 samples with different developers, hopefully this will go some way towards answering your query.

These two are with RO9 (Rodinal copy) with the film rated at 125, this gives negatives with very good accutance but a bit grainy, I think dilution of the RO9 was 1:10:




Two with Paterson FX-39, 1:14 dilution, this gave less grain than RO9 but similar accutance, again rated at ISO 125:




This was with Fomadon LQN, rated at 125, gave good accutance and grain, this was my preferred developer for FP4 before I discovered Microdol-X:




Sadly, I don't have any examples of FP4 in D76, but I expect the results would be very similar to what I got with Fomadon LQN.

My method for FP4 now is copied from Barry Thornton, for best results he wrote that you should rate it at half box speed (64) then develop in a simple Metol developer (Microdol-X, Ilford Perceptol or Thornton's 2-bath) and reduce dev time by 15%.

I find this gives me the best tonality I have got from FP4 and reduced grain. Accutance is slightly lower as you don't get the edge effects you get with RO9 and the grain reducing properties (the grain clumps together so the negatives are less grainy but this has a slight impact on accutance).

Sorry for the long-winded reply, but I hope that sort of answers your question.


Reply

Not long-winded at all. I always prefer thorough explanations. And I appreciate the primer you've provided on how the various developers perform with this film.

Oh, and by the way, that was a typo on my part. I know HP5 was ISO 400, and I should have typed FP4 instead of HP4.

Interesting that you overexpose by a stop. I've never tried that with Plus-X. What I'll most likely do before using any Ilford is go over to APUG and search their archives on the topic, maybe post a message if necessary. I wouldn't be surprised if I get info from them that dovetails with your process. I've gotten good advice from those folks in the past when I've had questions and/or problems with my B&W developing. I don't know who Barry Thornton is, but some of the folks over there probably do.


Reply

I figured it was a typo. Smile

Google Barry Thornton, he's sadly deceased but he has a website full of good info.

His 3-step Ultimate IQ method is really simple:

1. Rate at half box speed
2. Develop in simple Metol developer
3. Reduce development time over published info by 15%

Simple metol developers include Microdol-X, Ilford Perceptol and Barry Thornton's 2-bath.

At 1:1 Microdol-X is a grain reducing developer, but you lose some speed. Diluted 1:3 is behaves like D-76, no speed loss, grain is still reduced but not by as much, but what makes it great is the tonality it gives, in particular, it increases highlight detail.

There was a famous British freelance photographer of the 70s/80s called Raymond Lea, he mostly used FP4 in Microdol-X 1:3, and he said it gave him the easiest to print negatives he ever had.

The one downside to 1:3 Microdol-X is the long development times, I do 21 mins at 20C for FP4, which isn't a problem for me, but for some will be a drawback.


Reply

Ian,

I like this assorted set of samples, very enlightening.
From the first set, I like #7 fine details and gray spectrum and the three last landscapes.
From the second set, the first one with RO9 shows a nice balanced contrast with blacks and whites very clean.
Of course, all of them are nice, but those mentioned drew my attention immediately.

I got some stock of Tura P100 film (some 8-10 rolls), any hint on it?.


Reply

I have to agree with the others I love the landscapes and boats.I think you could get a really nice print from that boat scene.Would it be worth you going back (if you have time) with a few different lenses or cameras (perhaps that Kershaw that's in another thread) and take a few photos from different viewpoints.You have the developing down pat now for the next step grabbing that elusive best shot. Cool Very Happy


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 escribió:

His 3-step Ultimate IQ method is really simple:

1. Rate at half box speed
2. Develop in simple Metol developer
3. Reduce development time over published info by 15%

Simple metol developers include Microdol-X, Ilford Perceptol and Barry Thornton's 2-bath.

At 1:1 Microdol-X is a grain reducing developer, but you lose some speed. Diluted 1:3 is behaves like D-76, no speed loss, grain is still reduced but not by as much, but what makes it great is the tonality it gives, in particular, it increases highlight detail.

There was a famous British freelance photographer of the 70s/80s called Raymond Lea, he mostly used FP4 in Microdol-X 1:3, and he said it gave him the easiest to print negatives he ever had.

The one downside to 1:3 Microdol-X is the long development times, I do 21 mins at 20C for FP4, which isn't a problem for me, but for some will be a drawback.


So Ian, have you tried Thornton's 3-step Ultimate IQ method on other flavors of B&W film? I'm curious how it would work with Tri-X Professional, for example.


Reply

***There was a famous British freelance photographer of the 70s/80s called Raymond Lea, he mostly used FP4 in Microdol-X 1:3, and he said it gave him the easiest to print negatives he ever had***

In the old days IIRC Question Amateur Photographer magazine used my favourite Unitol for testing lenses...I've given up trying to find the formula or supply, on the net Sad


Reply

To overexpose 1 stop is quite strong, but no so unusual, especially when there is a combination of
slower than nominal film + fully exploiting developer
(developers that fully exploit a film's speed are actually rare).
A little underdevelopment combined to some overexposure is also a technique
used by someone to keep grain under control.


Reply

Jesito escribió:
Ian,

I like this assorted set of samples, very enlightening.
From the first set, I like #7 fine details and gray spectrum and the three last landscapes.
From the second set, the first one with RO9 shows a nice balanced contrast with blacks and whites very clean.
Of course, all of them are nice, but those mentioned drew my attention immediately.

I got some stock of Tura P100 film (some 8-10 rolls), any hint on it?.


Thankyou Luis.

The first ro9 one of the church window is with the Hexanon 1.4/50 wide open, it's a superb lens and the light was just right, it is the light that made the shot, I was just lucky to be there at the right time.

I know Tura rebadged films made by others, ther Tura Line was Agfa Copex microfilm they had added perforations to, so I'm not sure what P100 is, it's likely to be Agfa or Efke I think, or perhaps Filmotec/Orwo.

If you can't find any info on it I would treat it like Agfa 100 and then adjust devlopment times after seeing the results of the first roll. If you applied the Thorton 3-step method you would rate it at 50 then develop in Microdol-X (hard to find, but Ilford Perceptol is the same thing and easy to find) diluted 1:3 for 21mins at 20C.

Hope that helps, another guaranteed method is to do ro9 for 1 hour stand developed with 30 secs agitation to begin than another 30 after 30 mins, that will develop anything to completion but also gives reduced contrast. The lower contrast would probably be good for you as you often have bright sunlight to work with, and contrast is the easiest thing to correct in PP.


Reply

Excalibur escribió:
***There was a famous British freelance photographer of the 70s/80s called Raymond Lea, he mostly used FP4 in Microdol-X 1:3, and he said it gave him the easiest to print negatives he ever had***

In the old days IIRC Question Amateur Photographer magazine used my favourite Unitol for testing lenses...I've given up trying to find the formula or supply, on the net Sad

I don't think you'll have any luck. This site explains the history of Johnson's Unitol - it ended up with Patersons and
they only do their Acu range now.

Ilford LC29 seems to be quite similar to the old Unitol. I think it's really good, I use it all the time now.
http://www.ilfordphoto.com/products/product.asp?n=33&t=Film+Developers#


Reply

mo escribió:
I have to agree with the others I love the landscapes and boats.I think you could get a really nice print from that boat scene.Would it be worth you going back (if you have time) with a few different lenses or cameras (perhaps that Kershaw that's in another thread) and take a few photos from different viewpoints.You have the developing down pat now for the next step grabbing that elusive best shot. Cool Very Happy


Cheers Mo. I actually went there yesterday with David Lloyd and used the Kershaw, not very happy with the results though, came out too grainy for my liking. I have shot there in the past, it's a mile or so from my house.

This was with TMAX 100 developed in Paterson FX-39 and Konica Autoreflex T with Hexanon 3.5/200:




Same time and camera but with Hexanon 2.8/24:









Reply

cooltouch escribió:
iangreenhalgh1 escribió:

His 3-step Ultimate IQ method is really simple:

1. Rate at half box speed
2. Develop in simple Metol developer
3. Reduce development time over published info by 15%

Simple metol developers include Microdol-X, Ilford Perceptol and Barry Thornton's 2-bath.

At 1:1 Microdol-X is a grain reducing developer, but you lose some speed. Diluted 1:3 is behaves like D-76, no speed loss, grain is still reduced but not by as much, but what makes it great is the tonality it gives, in particular, it increases highlight detail.

There was a famous British freelance photographer of the 70s/80s called Raymond Lea, he mostly used FP4 in Microdol-X 1:3, and he said it gave him the easiest to print negatives he ever had.

The one downside to 1:3 Microdol-X is the long development times, I do 21 mins at 20C for FP4, which isn't a problem for me, but for some will be a drawback.


So Ian, have you tried Thornton's 3-step Ultimate IQ method on other flavors of B&W film? I'm curious how it would work with Tri-X Professional, for example.


Yes, I've tried it with several films and it has worked very well with all of them.

Polypan F 50:

http://forum.mflenses.com/polypan-f50-in-microdol-x-contax-iiia-biogon-2-8-35-t55487.html



Agfa Copex HDP13 Microfilm:

http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-8-t56343.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-7-t56292.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-6-snowy-scenes-t56290.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-5-t56206.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-4-t56190.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-3-t56175.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-2-t56154.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/agfa-copex-hdp13-in-kodak-microdol-x-t56126.html



Ilford FP4+ expired 1994:

http://forum.mflenses.com/ilford-fp4and-in-kodak-microdol-x-micro-nikkor-3-5-55-t56488.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/decay-ilford-fp4and-in-kodak-microdol-x-micro-nikkor-3-5-55-t56538.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/swans-ilford-fp4and-in-kodak-microdol-x-zenitar-m2s-t56536.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/1994-expired-ilford-fp4and-in-kodak-microdol-x-t55963.html



Ilford FP4 expired 1982:

http://forum.mflenses.com/1982-expired-ilford-fp4-in-kodak-microdol-x-t56063.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/1980s-ilford-fp4-in-kodak-microdol-x-t56042.html



Kodak Technical Pan expired 1982:

http://forum.mflenses.com/rusting-jags-kodak-technical-pan-in-kodak-microdol-x-t56599.html
http://forum.mflenses.com/kodak-technical-pan-2415-in-kodak-microdol-x-part-2-t56041.html



Fuji Neopan SS 100: (rated at 100)

http://forum.mflenses.com/fuji-neopan-ss-100-in-kodak-microdol-x-t55461.html



Fomapan 100: (rated at 100)

http://forum.mflenses.com/fomapan-100-in-microdol-x-contax-iiia-biogon-t55477.html



Editado por última vez por iangreenhalgh1 el Lun Feb 25, 2013 4:29 pm; editado 1 vez en total


Reply

peterqd escribió:
Excalibur escribió:
***There was a famous British freelance photographer of the 70s/80s called Raymond Lea, he mostly used FP4 in Microdol-X 1:3, and he said it gave him the easiest to print negatives he ever had***

In the old days IIRC Question Amateur Photographer magazine used my favourite Unitol for testing lenses...I've given up trying to find the formula or supply, on the net Sad

I don't think you'll have any luck. This site explains the history of Johnson's Unitol - it ended up with Patersons and
they only do their Acu range now.

Ilford LC29 seems to be quite similar to the old Unitol. I think it's really good, I use it all the time now.
http://www.ilfordphoto.com/products/product.asp?n=33&t=Film+Developers#


Thanks handy to know.
I sometimes think Exclamation was my favourite dev "Unitol" over rated as if it was that great why didn't someone carry on making\selling it Question
Same thoughts for my other favourite Photocolor II http://www.photomemorabilia.co.uk/Photo_Technology_Ltd.html


Reply

Best ever shots of boats and scenery, with pop as well.


Reply

Orio escribió:
To overexpose 1 stop is quite strong, but no so unusual, especially when there is a combination of
slower than nominal film + fully exploiting developer
(developers that fully exploit a film's speed are actually rare).
A little underdevelopment combined to some overexposure is also a technique
used by someone to keep grain under control.


I have found that a denser negative than would be ideal for printing with an enlarger is actually preferable for scanning, so the overexposure works for me. Also, I am using old expired film stocks so some loss of speed may have occurred so the overexposure may be a bit less than 1 stop when I rate at half speed.

Grain control, it seems to work, I have had pretty much grainless results with fine grained films like the Agfa Copex and Kodak Tech Pan and the grain is definitely reduced with other films.

I'm only just beginning to explore this technique really, have done quite a lot of rolls with it, I think about 30 rolls, a few of which were failures due to old film stocks that were no good - I shot 3 or 4 rolls of HP5 that had lost a lot of speed and had a very high level of base fog, those were not nice, and a few rolls of Kodalith that was similarly poor with lost speed and high base fog.

The only film I have tried with it where there seemed to be an issue that wasn't due to the condition of the film would be Fuji Neopan SS 100. The first roll I shot was 35mm and not bad, but grainier than it should have been. Yesterday I shot a second roll, 120, and the tonality and grain and not good, the grain has come out with a strange structure and is far more pronounced than I expected. Seems Microdol-X is not the best choice for Neopan. I have one more roll of Neopan left, I will try it in the Ornano ST20 I think.

Neopan SS 100 shot yesterday in my Kershaw 450 6x6 folder, rated at 50. Grain is high and of a strange structure:




Reply

Wow, the grain almost looks like honeycombs. Reminds me, I read somewhere that when masses of bubbles form, they naturally arrange themselves into six-sided figures. I wonder if that's what was going on here? But grain instead of bubbles?

Yeah, I thought I remembered that right. See here about bubbles and hexagonal shapes. Gotta skip down to the "Physics" section, though.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soap_bubble

So it's all about the natural tendency of any homogeneous group of things to attempt to occupy a minimal amount of space, and that turns out to be hexagonal arrangements if there are many items in the group, and these items are capable of being easily reshaped. Much of your "grain" is not hexagonal, but appears to be close enough, and appears to be attempting to follow this same sort of pattern. But my question is why would grain clump together like this, when clumping is something that one generally wants to avoid?

That would be a good bone for the folks over at APUG.org to chew on. They love stuff like this.


Reply

Aah, clumping, I have read that Microdol-X causes grain to clump together. It hasn't been apparent on any other films, just Neopan.

So, seems Neopan and Microdol-X don't play together well, oh well, lesson learnt.

I have a roll of TMAX 100 I did in Microdol-X to scan, fingers crossed that isn't also grainy like this. Maybe I have discovered that Microdol-X doesn't work so great with tabular grain emulsions?