MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

stoopid question: would the nikon d3100 accept ais lenses?
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

i just have no idea about these things. i have ais nikkor 50/2 and e35/2.5 that i use on my f2a ...


Reply

if i read the charts correctly, my ais lenses will work, but no meter ...


Reply

That's my understanding too.


Reply

fish4570 escribió:
... would the nikon d3100 accept ais lenses?

Yes. Both Ken Rockwell and Nikon agree.

Cita:
i just have no idea about these things. i have ais nikkor 50/2 and e35/2.5 that i use on my f2a ...


The Nikon 35/2.5 E has an Ais mount - so it's OK.

According to Roland Vink the Nikkor 50/2 Ais doesn't exist. The Ai is OK. Nikon say that the pre-Ai lenses will not work on the D3100. Ken, along with many others, disagrees.


Reply

The difference between Nikon and Ken Rockwell is that along with all the other internet wannabe-gurus, Ken doesn't face the threat of being sued by hundreds of thousands for product misinformation.


Reply

Yes I've got a ais nikkor 50 f1,8 and it works fine. Full manual only. But I got a dandelion chip from ebay and fitted it. Now it works like any other lens but without the autofocus.


Reply

Esox lucius escribió:
The difference between Nikon and Ken Rockwell is that along with all the other internet wannabe-gurus, Ken doesn't face the threat of being sued by hundreds of thousands for product misinformation.
Does that mean you're not a fan ? Wink


Reply

I'm 38 which is too old for being a fan of anyone.

I am a full-time photographer by profession, which gives me practical experience and knowledge of equipment Ken "reviews" without even holding in his hands... I do like Ken for the effort and energy he puts into supporting his growing family, but he knows a whole damn more about Google rankings than he knows about photographic equipment.

"In the land of the blind, the one-eyed is King."


Editado por última vez por Esox lucius el Sáb Nov 03, 2012 8:43 pm; editado 1 vez en total


Reply

Esox lucius escribió:
I'm not a fan of anyone, I'm 38 which is too old for being a fan of anyone. As I am a full-time photographer by profession it gives me practical experience and knowledge of equipment Ken "reviews" without even holding in his hands... I do like Ken for the effort and energy he puts into supporting his growing family, but in my eyes he is neither an expert nor knowledgeable enough to withstand the test of academically validated source criticism. He knows a whole damn more about Google rankings than he knows about photographic equipment.

"In the land of the blind, the one-eyed is King."
Ah, so you are not a fan then, but you think he is a humanitarian. Thanks for clearing that up.


Reply

I think he is much smarter than his camera "reviews" suggest, yes.

I just can't consider him a respectable source for photographic equipment reviews - some of the lenses he praises are in reality something else, something he would know if he actually had used them even once.


Reply

Esox lucius escribió:
I think he is much smarter than his camera "reviews" suggest, yes.

I just can't consider him a respectable source for photographic equipment reviews - some of the lenses he praises are in reality something else, something he would know if he actually had used them even once.


I don't know enough about photography to have a knowledgeable opinion on Ken, though i have come across debates about him, with people for and against. I respect you opinion as a professional though. I am ashamed to admit it, being a decade older than you, but i am still a fan of many things Embarassed Shocked Wink


Reply

In response to the original question, any AI, AIS, AF, AF-D, AF-S Nikkor will fit a Nikon D3100. AF and AF-D lenses will meter but not focus. AI and AIS lenses are total manual control. In addition, according to some authorities (http://www.bythom.com/lensacronyms.htm) but not others, pre-AI lenses fit on your D3100. And I used a 20mm f4 K on a D50 no problem (despite the coupling mismatch). But my 85mm f1.8 K could not be mounted on the D50. I'm not sure if that was simply the amount of wear on the 20mm's mount or not (and no, it had not been converted).

As far as Ken is concerned, I read him all the time. Some folks don't get that he purposely is provocative and preposterous and will say wild things to get a rise out of people like them. It's part of his schtick. He's kind of like some people on forums like this, except that he says it on his own website using his real name.


Reply

Hi

I use a D3000 and I use Ais, Ai and pre Ai lenses all the time. You get no metering so you have to guess the exposure or use an external light meter.

About pre AI lenses. I've used a 50/1.4, 50/2 and 135/2.8 with no problems. Also I've read that pre Ai lenses can be safely mounted on the entry level D3000, D3100, D5000, D5100 but NOT on D50, D70, D80, or any better camera. http://www.bythom.com/lensacronyms.htm

I don't know whether pre Ai lenses will mount on the D3200 or D5200.