MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Lady of the night
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

This one is from Trapani, Sicily. A wonderful picturesque small town, full of photographic opportunity. I visioned this picture in orange (that is what it looked in real life because of the lighting type), but I wanted to see the image in B&W as well. Now I can't decide which one to use. Please help me out. C&C also welcome.





Reply

Definitely in colour for me! Smile


Reply

Being a classic type, I vote for B&W.
By the way, nice work!


Reply

orange for me


Reply

poilu escribió:
orange for me


me 2


Reply

Orange is better. Warmer feel, less distant atmosphere.


Reply

David escribió:
Orange is better. Warmer feel, less distant atmosphere.


I agree....


Reply

Orange version for me. Different reason.
Orange is close to red in color spectrum and seeing the title and the picture I had in mind a red-light district.


Reply

looks like yellow to me, and i like the yellow best. this is a case of the color looking grittier than the BW ...


Reply

The colour version. Very nicely done.


Reply

Also +1 for color version
Very nice. Very good atmosphere.

A slightly thicker DOF would have been imher nicer though
The B/W version could have been warmer in tones


Reply

Orange me too.
But I expect see soon something about see/salt/wind of west Sicily colours Cool


Reply

I like B&W best. Orange is too orange for me; perhaps a deep red would work?


Reply

With B&W the figure's impact is more powerful and mysterious. I think this fits better with the fact that she's only a silhouette with no detail visible.
With orange, the environment becomes more important (and the person conversely less); for this reason I would expect some discernible detail in the woman
in the orange version, to fit better into the scene.

By the way, I wanted to ask: was she a local girl, or your wife/girlfriend serving you as model?


Reply

Thanks everyone! I do like both versions, but I think I will go with my instinct and use the original. Maybe I will make a new attempt at post processing the B&W version later on. Slightly warmer tones and a bit of grain maybe?

Orio: the girl is my girlfriend, we had a blast during the 10 minute session. A lot of confused people driving slowly by Smile


Reply

Orio escribió:
Being a classic type, I vote for B&W.
By the way, nice work!

+1


Reply

Orange for me, too.

The song Lalena by Donovan is running thru my head now.

And Sting's RoxanneSmile


Reply

I'm glad you like the picture guys!

Btw, I think I forgot to tell you that the picture was taken with the Contax G Zeiss 45/2 Planar wide open


Reply

I like both versions, but the colour version has something extra in the details. Maybe a bit more processing on the B&W would help, but I'm not sure what it needs.


Reply

I too think that the B&W version shows potential but I need to get more skilled in the conversion process. I'm happy with the colour version for now and later on, I can go back and work on the B&W version.


Reply

I think B+W suits the theme - a bit dark and wild.


patrickh


Reply

Hard to say ... I like both .It depends what do you want to emphasise . I'd go with the BW ,in the end ...The contour ,the shape is more important here than the color.