MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Comparison - Epson V700 and Nikon Coolscan V
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

Here are full crops from an image scanned at 2400dpi.
Both saved as jpegs with same level of compression (11 in Photoshop).
Both straight out of the scanners with no enhancement settings.
Not scientific, of course, but still a sort of "real world" look.

Nikon:


Epson:


Nikon scan looks better, but the Epson is surprising in the comparison.


Reply

Nikon looks so much better to me.


Reply

Orio escribió:
Nikon looks so much better to me.


Agree, much sharper detail. Let's see how that Nikon does with 120! Twisted Evil


Reply

Looks like the Nikon is getting detail in the shadows better.


Reply

Yes, pretty obvious. Cool

Bill, the Nikon won't scan 120. It is a "dedicated" scanner for 35mm film and slides. But if you want, you
could buy me a dedicated scanner that will scan both formats! Laughing I agree on the shadow detail, again
pretty darn obvious.

The slide was Velvia, using a Tamron SP 80-210/2.8 at about 90mm focal.


Reply

Damn Nikon for not making scanners anymore Crying or Very sad


Reply

GrahamNR17 escribió:
Damn Nikon for not making scanners anymore Crying or Very sad


Nikon was expensive but drum scanners might start to become cheaper Wink
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Imacon-Flextight-Photo-Virtual-Drum-Film-Scanner-/300649820125?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4600202fdd


Editado por última vez por Excalibur el Lun Ene 16, 2012 10:57 pm; editado 1 vez en total


Reply

Something that is REALLY eye-opening is that the Epson 2450 Photo scanned as well as the Epson V700 Photo, at least
in my opinion, at 2400dpi with 120 slide film. I spent a little money last year on 2 identical prints at 16x20, one from each scanner.
No difference that I could see. Surprised The difference in price of the scanners is huge.


Reply

Excalibur escribió:
GrahamNR17 escribió:
Damn Nikon for not making scanners anymore Crying or Very sad


Nikon was expensive but drum scanners might start to become be cheaper Wink
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Imacon-Flextight-Photo-Virtual-Drum-Film-Scanner-/300649820125?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4600202fdd
3 grand Shocked Cheaper but not cheap enough Crying or Very sad

That said, I'm getting fabulous results now with a Samsung GX10 and Ohnar. I'll do similar comparisons to Laurence's and post in another thread.


Reply

GrahamNR17 escribió:
Excalibur escribió:
GrahamNR17 escribió:
Damn Nikon for not making scanners anymore Crying or Very sad


Nikon was expensive but drum scanners might start to become be cheaper Wink
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Imacon-Flextight-Photo-Virtual-Drum-Film-Scanner-/300649820125?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4600202fdd
3 grand Shocked Cheaper but not cheap enough Crying or Very sad

That said, I'm getting fabulous results now with a Samsung GX10 and Ohnar. I'll do similar comparisons to Laurence's and post in another thread.


Yes, those drum scanners are still going down in price! I would love to see some comparisons, Graham. It benefits all of us.


Reply

Nikon all the way for me Laurence. I have been going through the same thing with my Epson. A really good scanner but lacking in 35mm.


Reply

Laurence, a NIB Nikon Coolscan 9000 is being overnighted to you via FedEx! PSYCH!! Laughing

The V is definitely doing a nice job with 35mm, though.


Reply

erm no member from China for an opinion on their scanners Question


Reply

I think that it's the focus that lets the Epson down, although Attila seems to get good results.


Reply

The Imacon is a SCSI-II device ;(

From the auction:

* Sensor: Single pass trilinear CCD array with 24,000 pixel elements
* Optical Resolution: 3200dpi
* Density Range: 3.9 with 4.1 D-max

Canon 5Dc:

* Sensor is CMOS 35.8mm x 23.9mm with 4368 x 2912 = 12,719,616 pixels
* Optical Resolution: about 3000ppi.
* Density Range: about 7 stops dynamic range, however that equates to D-max

Does that mean Canon 5Dc and bellows with quality lens and slide-copy attachment can make as good a 'scan' of 35mm film as Imacon drum scanner?


Editado por última vez por visualopsins el Mar Ene 17, 2012 8:35 am; editado 1 vez en total


Reply

Isn't it slightly less than 3000ppi effective resolution for the Canon?
Camera has 'scans' a frame about 1' high for 135 film right, regardless of the size of the sensor of the camera?


Reply

Ymmot escribió:
Isn't it slightly less than 3000ppi effective resolution for the Canon?
Camera has 'scans' a frame about 1' high for 135 film right, regardless of the size of the sensor of the camera?


Thanks! I corrected the original post...

2912p / 23.9mm * 25.4mm/in = 3095ppi
4368p / 35.8mm * 25.4mm/in = 3099ppi


Reply

The result are as expected...
For scanning both formats ,probably it's mor economical to use the Nikon V for 35 and Epson flatbed 4990 0r V700 for 120


Reply

martinsmith99 escribió:
I think that it's the focus that lets the Epson down, although Attila seems to get good results.


Good point, Martin. I've actually spent a whole day last year trying to shim the slides to improve the focus. I finally found
that the best focus for slides was a tiny bit higher than the gap between the slide mount and the transparency plane would give.
I use 5 sheets of normal copy paper thickness under the cardboard slide mounts to achieve this increased gap. In my case at
least, this gives me the best focus. Although, I think that this is not optimum, it's what I use, including on this particular scan.

I think that, if Epson had incorporated an auto-focus AND manual focus capability, a guy could certainly do better.


Reply

yinyangbt escribió:
The result are as expected...
For scanning both formats ,probably it's mor economical to use the Nikon V for 35 and Epson flatbed 4990 0r V700 for 120


Yes, I think that makes sense. Now, it's a decision if I really want to (or can) spend the $$$ on the Nikon... Wink


Reply

Laurence escribió:
yinyangbt escribió:
The result are as expected...
For scanning both formats ,probably it's mor economical to use the Nikon V for 35 and Epson flatbed 4990 0r V700 for 120


Yes, I think that makes sense. Now, it's a decision if I really want to (or can) spend the $$$ on the Nikon... Wink
Your whole photographic process tends to demonstrate that you are not particularly fond of compromise. You are, I imagine, as particular about your camera, lens and film choice as you are about point of focus and composition. No point falling at the final hurdle.

Sell your furniture if you have to, but that scanner was made for your images Wink


Reply

Laurence escribió:
yinyangbt escribió:
The result are as expected...
For scanning both formats ,probably it's mor economical to use the Nikon V for 35 and Epson flatbed 4990 0r V700 for 120


Yes, I think that makes sense. Now, it's a decision if I really want to (or can) spend the $$$ on the Nikon... Wink

I fully understand you.
That depends on how much are you going to scan in the future. If you are going to scan only your archive is one thing ,if you are planning to do 35mm film shooting in the future, It seems that a V makes sense . I don't. Because of the lack of good labs in my area , I plan to shoot film only occasionally ,let's say max 10 rolls/year , so my 80 E Minolta Dimage III fits perfectly for the job.
You can check also the Minolta Dimage Elite 5400 (I or II) and also the Canon FS4000 .It seems they are cheaper (at least the Canon).
But that depends on how much that $$$ is Wink


Reply

Well, I am lucky here, in that I can use the Coolscan for about 2 months more before having to
return it to the owner. In fact, that is very nice, as I think I can get through at least SOME of the
"better images" in the over 500 boxes of slides. Shocked

I've already looked at 20 boxes of slides last night on the light box, and picked out about a dozen
"better images" out of those 600+ slides. It's a rather fast way of deciding which are good enough,
but seems to work okay. Trying to be VERY picky about it. If I can average looking at 20 boxes daily,
I can complete the review and selections of the 500 boxes in about 3 weeks (but better make it 4-5
weeks realistically).

My major thrust is to my Pentax 645 and the Epson V700 to scan the medium format slides. I have
had great luck with imagery and scanning with that combination. Also, since the P645 is my all-time
favorite, I'll more than likely stick with it for film.

I'm still not sure where I'll end up with digital. Right now I'm back, once again, to the old Minolta A-1
which seems to fulfill what I need right now, even at "just" 6MP.

I also bought some FINE Russian lenses that adapt to the P645, from Tony (rbelyell). He is a great all
around guy, and I am pleased with the lenses. Test shots show these to be every bit as good for my
own style of shooting as the more expensive (right now, anyway) Pentax-A lenses. In fact, they look
VERY good, but perhaps that's because I'm not a "pixel peeper" and really only base that on what I
see on the lightbox and from the scanner as a result of the Russion glass.

Here one from the Pentax 645 / Epson scanner combination:



The V700 reaches into the shadows pretty well with medium format transparencies. This slide goes from
extremely bright sunshine on the right, and extremely dark shadows on the upper left. It is a tough
shot to "nail", but I think the combination did an admirable job.


]http://forum.mflenses.com/userpix/20121/65_Battered_Driftwood_Web_1.jpg[/img][/url]


Editado por última vez por Laurence el Mar Ene 17, 2012 9:12 pm; editado 1 vez en total


Reply

I am glad you choice this Larry, I did follow you and my forever favorite set just same.