MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Nikon non-AI lenses usable with pro bodies?
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

I read two articles from LensTip.com comparing old Nikkor-S 5.8cm/f1.4 and 5 cm/f2.0 non-Ai lenses with modern Nikkor lenses.

The articles state, that:
"The Nikkor –S 5 cm f/2.0 is one of the oldest F mount lenses so it belongs to the type frequently described as a non-AI so without the aperture ring-light meter cooperation mechanism, called AI (Automatic Indexing) and introduced in 1977. The lenses, manufactured after that date had a hook on the aperture ring and its position depended on the aperture. Early bodies with the AI system were connected to this hook using a little lever, which, when the non-AI lenses were used, could be lifted up. The modern bodies doesn’t have a possibility to lift that little lever so there were some doubts whether or not we would manage to attach such old lenses to a body of, say, a D3x. It turned out that the lever is very thin so the lens’s body slides beneath and it stays fixed after the connection. By contrast, the AI lenses move the lever by a value depending on the maximum relative aperture. It creates a problem, though. Even if the body has a possibility to save the information about the used Non-CPU lens, some strange data often find its way to the EXIF. Although the focal length is saved correctly, the active aperture is not. In EXIF we find the most often the lens’s maximum aperture, regardless of the aperture that was really used. It happened from time to time that the body got silly and just saved some random aperture values. "

I have always thought, that the older lenses are not compatible with high-end Nikon bodies. Have anybody else tried and used non-Ai lenses with D200,D300,D700,D700 or D3 bodies?

Here´s a link:
http://www.lenstip.com/117.1-article-50_years_of_Nikon_F-mount_%E2%80%93_Nikkor-S_5_cm_f_2_vs._Nikkor_AF_50_mm_f_1.8D.html


Reply

It is far more complicated than that. The Nikkormat FT3, EL2, Nikon FE, FM, F3, F4 and (apparently - I haven't ever seen it that closely) F6 have a AI coupler that can be disengaged - additionally Nikon modified some F5es with the F4 coupler. All lesser and later cameras are pre-AI incompatible by Nikon definition.

That said, the post-AI cameras (i.e. all D series DSLRs that don't meter with AI lenses) don't have a AI coupler that could get into the way any more - but they may have other issues. Many pre-AI lenses will mount on the all-electronic D40/D60 and Dx000 consumer DSLRs without damaging them - but they don't meter properly, so Nikon lists them as unsupported. Be cautious and don't force anything, a few old lenses habe been reported to damage the contacts.

Don't try on cameras with rigid AI couplers (all AI film cameras except for those mentioned above, the pro digital cameras, and a few more). And don't even try on cameras that have a camera side AF motor unless you have previously made double sure that the particular lens you want to try has no ridges in the flange inside which the drive pin may come stuck - there are some pre-AI (and even some AI converted) lenses where a mounting attempt will convert the body and lens into a fixed lens camera that cannot be separated again without sacrificing either lens or body.


Editado por última vez por Sevo el Mar Ene 31, 2012 8:24 am; editado 5 veces en total


Reply

The generally accepted view is that attempting to mount a pre-Ai lens on a high end body - one with a coupling lever will damage the camera - specifically the lever. The lenstip link says that the edge of the aperture ring sits beneath the lever. However they also report variable aperture values reported in the EXIF. So presumably there is some coupling between the aperture ring and the lever - via friction. Maybe damage can be caused if this "coupling" is too great ?


Reply

Sevo escribió:

And don't even try on cameras that have a camera side AF motor unless you have previously made double sure that the particular lens you want to try has no ridges in the flange inside which the drive pin may come stuck - there are some pre-AI (and even some AI converted) lenses where a mounting attempt will convert the body and lens into a fixed lens camera that cannot be separated again without sacrificing either lens or body.


could you please give an example ? never have seen a risk here, maybe i only was lucky with Nikon


Reply

56 DIN escribió:

could you please give an example ? never have seen a risk here, maybe i only was lucky with Nikon


I've had a sixties 2.5/105 stuck on a D70, and had to have the mount forced off the latter to get it unstuck. The service man said he had seen it happen with other lenses as well, that I was lucky that it happened on a cheap body, and that there was a reason to Nikon stating that pre AI lenses did not fit. On the other hand, nothing has ever come stuck on my D50 or D90. However I never dared to try that 105mm on a DSLR again - but my K 1.4/50 and F 3.5/135 (both quite a bit later than the 105mm) seem to be safe on the D50 at least.


Reply

Thank you for comments.

I don´t have any pre-Ai lenses, and I understand that everyone should be very cautious to mounting them to bodies with a coupling lever.
I think, that Nikon is very conservative with their recommendations, somewhere I read, that a K-ring set is not compatible, but I have one, and there´s never been a problem with my D200 and D700 bodies.

So old Nikkor lenses may or may not be usable with the high-end digital bodies - everyone who´s trying, is doing it at their own risk.


Reply

o.k., was looking at the old 105mm and the newer on and some other old lenses. The real old Nikkors have 5 slotted screws, similiar to the drive coupling of the AF lenses situated at the same radius - only the slot is thinner, but i would not rely on that. The newer Nikkors like 105 AI (s) have 3 cross/phillips screws, maybe the slot at old Nikkors is a risky point. One screw of the elder versions might slide over the drive ....
thanks for sharing


Reply

Looking at the lenses again, my 105 has slotted screws (and the one opposite the AF drive is almost axial to the mount), while the newer ones have JIS (Philips like) - I suppose the drive pin will slide out of the cross screw heads, as they have a slope, while it may fail to come out of the slotted screws if the slot is at that angle. That will have a easy fix in replacing the screws with Philips-headed ones (or filling the slot with epoxy).


Reply

Okay, so here's how this works:

The high-end Nikons, up to the F4, have an AI link that flips back. It locks in place until you push a button on the ring then the little nub flips up. The F5 and F6 can be modded to have that by nikon but do not come out of the box that way. NAI (or pre-AI) lenses damage any camera with a coupling link (the nub) that cannot flip up. Likewise, using an NAI lens on a high-end camera WITHOUT flipping up the link will also damage it. By damage it I mean break the link off and send it shooting across the room like a tiddlywink.

The D3000 and D3100, and some Nikon film SLRs, can mount all lenses because they lack the coupling. I believe the N55, N2002, N4004, etc., are Nikons without the coupling.

So the high-end DSLRs -- D100 to 300 and so forth -- can be damaged by NAI lenses because they do not have a flippable coupling. The D1-4 series, I believe, either come with a flippable coupling or can be modded by Nikon.

So, in short, do not use an NAI lens on your valuable Nikon unless it has a flippable coupling nub or no coupling nub. Alternately, you can get AIS modded NAI lenses (a but more expensive now because they can work on DSLRs) or have your NAI lens modded. Nikon no longer mods lenses, though, so you have to find someone who knows how to do it and has a machine shop. Oh, and you have to accept that your NAI lens will be effectively valueless because it has a non-Nikon mod. And if the mod is done improperly, there's no reversing it.