MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

NEX-5N v NX200
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

I'm trying hard to choose. Anyone using an NX200?




Pros and cons anyone?
I like the standard hotshoe on the NX but I like peak focus on the NEX.
I like 20.3MP on the NX v 16.1MP on the NEX
I like 25,600 IOS on the NEX v 12,800 on the NX
But the NX looks much sexier! Smile

(Pics from dpreview.com)


Reply

NEX... due peak focusing feature if NX 200 has still 2x magnify as focusing aid.


Reply

What do you think are the chances of Samsung upgrading the firmware with peak focus, like Sony did? Eveyone os putting it on their Facebook page (Jes included) Smile


Reply

Peter, I'd vote for the NEX5N, it has that magic sensor like the K-5. 16MP is more than enough. Whichever you choose I'm sure that you'll love the amazing ratio of camera size to image quality and being able to take shots from more interesting angle without being like a contortionist or lying on the floor and being able to do candids easily.


Reply

From what I understand, there seem to be a lot more adapters available for Nex than for the Nx.
I think that for a manual lens user this is an important detail.


Reply

Thanks William. I don't think I'll ever need 25,600 ISO and 16.1 MP is more than adequate as you say, so those considerations aren't worth thinking about for me. The standard hotshoe on the NX is a big tick for me though - I somehow feel annoyed with manufacturers who confine you to using only their own accessories. I understand the battery on the NEX is like that too.

Tell me more about the sensors - what sensor does the NX200 have? The pictures I've seen from the NX100 and NX11 look fine to me.


Reply

I was looking Jes pics of Barcelona and I found the NX100 of jlsa05 sexy
I don't know which lens jlsa05 was using but the look is great


Reply

Orio escribió:
From what I understand, there seem to be a lot more adapters available for Nex than for the Nx.
I think that for a manual lens user this is an important detail.

Thanks Orio, that's an important point, but Ludoo has told me that all the adapters I'll ever need are already available for the NX.
http://forum.mflenses.com/samsung-nx-t44809.html


Reply

Orio escribió:
From what I understand, there seem to be a lot more adapters available for Nex than for the Nx.
I think that for a manual lens user this is an important detail.


+1 also.


Reply

Attila escribió:
NEX... due peak focusing feature if NX 200 has still 2x magnify as focusing aid.


The Samsung may have the better native lenses, but

the LCD of the NEX tilting allows for easily taking lower and other POVs, this is a great advantage I would not want to do without.

so far I am very impressed by the peak focusing of my NEX5N, seems that it is that accurate that it even guides me to focus a f1.4 lens wide open fast and precisely


Reply

Neither camera is a bad one, Peter. Wink

I'd go for the NEX. What do you need more than 20 MPix for?

If there was an NEX-6 with all the features of the NEX-7 but the sensor of the NEX-5N, I would surely go for that "6".


The Samsung surely is not bad either, but I guess - even if the adapters you need are available - the NEX is more versatile.
As far as I know, you cannot use Leica M glass on an NX. Even if you don't have one now, you might find the "bargain of the century" and then you can't use your 100quid Summilux-M 35 Wink on your NX! Shocked


Reply

I got both a NEX-C3 and a NX100.

There is an additional advantage of the NEX over the NX: the register distance, that is shorter on the NEX (25.5mm on the NX vs 18mm on the NEX). Taking into account the Leica-M lenses as a reference, they have 27.8mm, so an adapter for the NX without a lens is questionable (2.3mm for the adapter).

This allows for more lenses to be mounted on the NEX than on the NX.

I use the NEX for MF lenses, and the NX as my "compact" cam AF, with two lenses: the 20-50 (the one is wearing the NX100 of Jlsa05 at the picture) and the 50-200 OIS.
I got a M42 adapter for the NX, just for playing, but focusing is much harder on it than on the NEX.
I also got a FD adapter from Ludoo for my Tokina 28mm 2.8 that I want to use on the NX as well.

No further investment from my side on the NX...

My sincere recommendation for MF Lenses is to go for the NEX (any of them).

Regards.
Jes.


Reply

DXOMark have scored the Nex-7 higher than the Nex-5N Shocked I might have to save for the Nex-7 now... Laughing


Reply

ManualFocus-G escribió:
DXOMark have scored the Nex-7 higher than the Nex-5N Shocked I might have to save for the Nex-7 now... Laughing


no small feat the NEX7 outscored the 5N, neither passed Pentax K5 though
I am happy with my choice of 5N, just as I like the LCD tilting so I like the EVF tilting too Wink


Reply

What a fantastic place this is. Just imagine how naked Id feel if I was going into a shop without the benefit of all this wisdom. Thank you all so much. Jes, I was waiting for you to comment because I knew you have both types of camera, if not the same models.

It certainly looks like the NEX is the favourite, but it seems nobody here has actually tried the NX200. Reading the reviews, it's a very different camera to the NX100 and I like very much the more normal controls, it appeals to me and I think it deserves to be checked out. One things's for certain - if I don't check it out I'll never know if I made the right choice.

The hotshoe isn't a major importance I guess. More important is the lack of an exposure lock button, no socket for an EVF and the non-swivelling display.


Reply

This maybe interesting to consider:
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/sony_nex_7_rolling_review.shtml#28


Reply

Obviously if one has the money, the Nex 7 is to prefer. The slight drawback at ISO above 1600
is more than compensated by the magnification advantage at lower ISO.

In a way, it's a similar situation to that of the criticism to the Leica M9. People accuses "why spend so much a camera
that performs poorly at ISO 2500?"
The answer for me is simple: because at ISO160-200-400 the quality is such that it simply blows away any other digital camera
that I know of in small format. At ISO 800-1600 these is some noise but perfectly manageable. Performance becomes really critical at
ISO 2500, undeniably.
But what most people don't realize is, that I take 90% of my photos at ISO from 160 to 400, and 9% at ISO from 800 to 1600.
Only one photo out of one hundred (just for the sake of example, in reality it's much less) I take at ISO 2500.
So I should give up 99% of absolutely terrific mind-blowing photos, only because the remaining 1% of photos kind of suck?

So for me the choice would be the same for Nex 7. I would consider more important the larger size of low ISO pictures than the
slightly worse noise of the occasional high ISO image.


Reply

My current (and only) digi camera is a Canon 400D. The lowest ISO is 100 and the highest only 1600. 400 is noisy and 800 is unacceptable. This is ancient technology today, but remember I've been using slow films all my photo life - as low as 25 in the days of Kodachrome II, and even today I don't like films higher than 200. So a high ISO (above 400) is simply the icing on the cake for me and I could easily get by without it.

Let's drop all talk about the NEX-7 please. It's out of range, just like an M9 or G2 lenses. Smile


Reply

peterqd escribió:
My current (and only) digi camera is a Canon 400D. The lowest ISO is 100 and the highest only 1600. 400 is noisy and 800 is unacceptable. This is ancient technology today, but remember I've been using slow films all my photo life - as low as 25 in the days of Kodachrome II, and even today I don't like films higher than 200. So a high ISO (above 400) is simply the icing on the cake for me and I could easily get by without it.

Let's drop all talk about the NEX-7 please. It's out of range, just like an M9 or G2 lenses. Smile


Peter, I would buy a Nex-3
I am thinking of doing that myself


Reply

Orio escribió:
Peter, I would buy a Nex-3
I am thinking of doing that myself

Orio, you will not be happy with a Nex or anything with a Sony sensor
the hardware noise reduction introduce artifacts in the raw even at base 200 iso
for someone coming from film on non cooked sensor it is a step back


Reply

poilu escribió:
Orio escribió:
Peter, I would buy a Nex-3
I am thinking of doing that myself

Orio, you will not be happy with a Nex or anything with a Sony sensor
the hardware noise reduction introduce artifacts in the raw even at base 200 iso
for someone coming from film on non cooked sensor it is a step back


Really? Also in RAW? That's a bummer. Thanks for informing me of this.
I don't actually "need" a Nex camera if you know what I mean, but it would be a nice small cam to use for Monica
when we go somewhere, and (mostly) I am lured by temptation of using lenses that
I can not currently mount on neither the EOS nor the M9, notably my Contax G lens set, or the Contarex Planar 2/50.
But, I can live without it for sure - in fact I did not buy it yet, I almost did when I was pointed to a price very favorable
but it turned out that the seller was a scammer.


Reply

Orio escribió:

Peter, I would buy a Nex-3
I am thinking of doing that myself

I bought a NEX-5N a few days ago, and I love it!
The idea of "loving" a Sony camera is strange for me Smile
Can't wait for the adapters to arrive...


Reply

nkanellopoulos escribió:

I bought a NEX-5N a few days ago


I think N is the expensive one, right? The newer one (I am confused by all the coding)


Reply

Orio escribió:
nkanellopoulos escribió:

I bought a NEX-5N a few days ago


I think N is the expensive one, right? The newer one (I am confused by all the coding)


Yes N, is the Newer model (16.1 MP).


Reply

Orio escribió:
poilu escribió:
Orio escribió:
Peter, I would buy a Nex-3
I am thinking of doing that myself

Orio, you will not be happy with a Nex or anything with a Sony sensor
the hardware noise reduction introduce artifacts in the raw even at base 200 iso
for someone coming from film on non cooked sensor it is a step back


Really? Also in RAW? That's a bummer. Thanks for informing me of this.
I don't actually "need" a Nex camera if you know what I mean, but it would be a nice small cam to use for Monica
when we go somewhere, and (mostly) I am lured by temptation of using lenses that
I can not currently mount on neither the EOS nor the M9, notably my Contax G lens set, or the Contarex Planar 2/50.
But, I can live without it for sure - in fact I did not buy it yet, I almost did when I was pointed to a price very favorable
but it turned out that the seller was a scammer.


Orio, don't let poilu talk you into the Sony-sensor-bashing!
I love my NEX-3 and I can't wait to get the NEX-7 I have pre-ordered.

Even with those internal algorithms, the images are much better than those taken with most other cams.

We all know that poilu is a hardcore film-fan and that he believes that no digital sensor will ever reach the results you get from film.


Let me put it that way:

Let's imagine, that the NEX-7 offers 95% of the NEX-5N performance at very high ISO, ok.
Then those 95% would still be more than the 80% that most other cams would offer at those high ISO settings.

The same is true for Sony image quality. The new NEXes offer (as you mention in your analogy to the M9) such a high IQ that even some internal algorithms (if you really can spot them in the pictures! That still needs to be shown.) cannot deteriorate the IQ so much that it would not be a considerable step ahead from most existing digicams.

And when talking about high ISO performance, like ISO 6400, and the resulting IQ loss, what about ISO 6400 film?
I would bet a lot on that the Sony NEX-7 sensor is many times better at ISO 6400 than any ISO6400 film ever was.

BTW, the new Nikons (e.g. the D7000) also have Sony sensors. I guess that is why they are so bad and nobody likes them, right? Rolling Eyes