MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Ardèche
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

Here are some photos from last summer.
We went in Ardèche in south of France and I used a polarizer with Tamron AF 28-75mm f:2.8 and 5D MkII

I like the rendering of this combo.

1-

2-

3-

4-

5-

6-

7-


Editado por última vez por Olivier el Lun Nov 21, 2011 9:22 pm; editado 4 veces en total


Reply

Sooo beautiful! The first one really gets you after a while. At first you don't see the figures on the beach below and when you do the scale amazes.


Reply

What an amazing place! And stunning photos!


Reply

Place is amazing, lens performance or/and filter very bad. What a pitty you didn't have better lens there.


Reply

I have to agree with Attila, either lens or filter not good as the images are rather flat and have no depth, contrast is equal all over frame and fairly flat, this is probably due to polariser. Lack of detail is more likely the lens. Would love to see same place shot with 5Dmk2 and a good manual lens as I feel this lensisn't getting the best from the camera.


Reply

Attila escribió:
Place is amazing, lens performance or/and filter very bad. What a pitty you didn't have better lens there.

+1 amazing place!


Reply

Thanx for your comments.

About the lens, I don't think it is bad. In this case it's the photographer... Embarassed
I checked the exif and I don't know how I managed to take pics #3, #6 and #7 at... f4... Confused


Reply

I think the polariser played a part, probably be more 'punch' without it.


Reply

But...
I just notice that when I click on pictures and they open in new window they are awful.
Could it be the resampling and treatment for uploading it ?


Reply

Olivier escribió:
But...
I just notice that when I click on pictures and they open in new window they are awful.
Could it be the resampling and treatment for uploading it ?

No , uploading , re sampling works well.

Resize your files to 1024px and open them locally with your browser and look them. You should not find any difference vs uploaded pictures.

I use ACDSEE to view and manipulate pictures it shows better pictures than browsers. Perhaps this is key in your case too, your picture manipulation software shows better pictures and those are okay.


Reply

I like the first one. Colours are rendered well on my screen.
What CPL did you use?


Reply

What a stunning place for a holiday, and stunning pictures of it too, Olivier!

I know where Ardeche is (not far from Valence,), I went there once on the way to the Cote D'Azur, but where exactly is that natural arch?


Reply

peterqd escribió:
What a stunning place for a holiday, and stunning pictures of it too, Olivier!

I know where Ardeche is (not far from Valence,), I went there once on the way to the Cote D'Azur, but where exactly is that natural arch?

Here I guess but Olivier will correct me if I'm wrong!:
http://www.vallon-pont-darc.com/site/vallon-pont-d-arc/discover/natural-reserve/3454-1315,natural-reserve.htm

That's for sure one of the most beautiful place from France but in the summer, it's very very warm and above that, it's very very busy Sad ....I've been there two or three times in the summer but I would love to go back in spring, I guess the best period to really enjoy this amazing place....

About the pictures, I found it really good on my screen, especially when it's open in a new window Smile .....


Reply

pich900 escribió:
peterqd escribió:
What a stunning place for a holiday, and stunning pictures of it too, Olivier!

I know where Ardeche is (not far from Valence,), I went there once on the way to the Cote D'Azur, but where exactly is that natural arch?

Here I guess but Olivier will correct me if I'm wrong!:
http://www.vallon-pont-darc.com/site/vallon-pont-d-arc/discover/natural-reserve/3454-1315,natural-reserve.htm

That's for sure one of the most beautiful place from France but in the summer, it's very very warm and above that, it's very very busy Sad ....I've been there two or three times in the summer but I would love to go back in spring, I guess the best period to really enjoy this amazing place....

About the pictures, I found it really good on my screen, especially when it's open in a new window Smile .....


If you use the satellite view from google and follow the Ardeche river you come to it (well looks like it from the air), the D290 is near.


Reply

I literally get a warm feeling by viewing those pictures... As I have been there on vacation 3 times. And indeed, Vallon-Pont d'Arc it is. I used to swim upstreams to right under the arch, and there are lots of small caves under the arch.

Also notable is that the famous Grotte Chauvet is very close. It's not accessible for visitors (for good reasons) but as you can see the area is full of natural and human history. Definitely worth a visit! But not necessarily during summer, as the Ardeche is commonly called the bake oven of France. I have personally experienced temperatures well above 40 degrees Celsius in summer, so in reality we never came out of the Ardeche river, only to sleep and eat Smile

About the pictures: they look very good on my monitor, but indeed not remarkable. Should they? They are vacation photos after all...


Reply

Found it! Thanks Smile

Yes, it was 42° when we overnighted at Valence, I think it was 1988 or 89. It had been 13° when we left Le Havre at 08.00 that morning. I was driving a Volvo 240GTE without aircon, and the first thing we did after parking the car was jump in the pool fully clothed (well, tee shirt and shorts) Smile


Reply

Yes, it is near Vallon Pont d'Arc. Very Happy

You're all right when you say it's better go there in spring. It was really very hot.
When we started from Boulogne sur Mer where I live, near Calais, it was raining and 13°C... typically british weather sent by Peter & Co Wink When we arrived in Ardeche, it was sunny, no clouds and 36°C. Thermal shock ! Embarassed Cool

http://g.co/maps/zbjbn
click on the pics on the left of the screen.

About the "Grotte Chauvet" : the cave of Chauvet.
http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/arcnat/chauvet/en/index.html


Reply

The photos can still partially be rescued:

BEFORE:



AFTER:



I think there are two factors that put together have a negative effect: the high sun light, and the polarizer.
High sun light is almost perpendicular, and casts very short shadows, that do not shape much the landscape;
The polarizer has the characteristic that it makes images flatter, because it cuts the highlights.
The two factors together have impacted hard the dimensionality, as it is evident for instance in photo #2
Additionally, except for a few almost burned highlights, most of the photo is underexposed, no doubt the 5DII
exposimeter was betrayed by the polarizer.
Another problem that the polarizer causes is that the water of the river, losing all the sparkles of the highlights, looks like mud.

Like I have shown, with some advanced editing, it is still possible to rescue the photos at least partially: of course,
the things killed by the polarizer (like the water sparkles) are lost forever.

Before using the polarizer, it is important to analyze the scene, and decide if the highlights do play an important role
in the image - if they do, better not to use the polarizer.
As a general rule, better to keep in mind that polarizer flattens the image, so it is best avoided when the sun casts short shadows, as at noon. At noon, better to only use an UV filter.


Reply

I agree with Orio's analysis and edit although would move the blues to a slightly more purpley hue. To me the photo after the edit screams modern Pentax in colour and is the type that I'd love to make again and again given a more cooperative climate.


Reply

Beautiful/magical place, thanks for sharing! Cool


Reply

What a nice place indeed Olivier!


Reply

The edited version looks much worse, it has too much noise and the colours are way off.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 escribió:
The edited version looks much worse, it has too much noise and the colours are way off.

Ian, you have to take into account that Orio did this editing on a 1200x800 sRGB file.
Orio's purpose is to show us what could have been photograped without the polarizer.

I find Orio's analysis interesting.
I didn't chose the hour to be there and couldn't go back there at a better moment. Imagine a sunset on this arch !
But I was in vacation with hole family and won't bother them.

I decided to use the polarizer to enhance the sky and avoid the harsh sparklings on the water.
Experiment makes experience. I know now, thanks to Orio that C-PL flattens and is not always a good tool.
Next time, I'll double them to keep a virgin image without any filters.

Ian, please, be more cool in your comments. Cool
Maybe you didn't have much time to write more, but your sentence can be taken as rude. I don't want agressive reactions or polemics in this topic. Thank you in davance Wink


Reply

Following Orio's analysis, I looked at my pictures and changed 3 things :
1/ applied daylight white balance.
2/ added some color saturation
3/ lowered brightness 1 step

I use Canon's Raw software Digital Photo Professional.

Here is the file in 1650x900



And I found 2 pictures taken with polarizer on but rotated differently.
I changed WB too, to apply day light.






About the Polarizer, it is a 67mm Hoya Pro1 Digital Filter Circular PL.

Post Scriptum : I don't know what happens with the DPP raw conversion to jpeg, as I loose lot of details in comparison with my original raw files. I 'll try with Lightroom instead... does anybody have operating advice to make the best Raw/Jpeg conversion ? Thanx in advance. Smile