MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Damned Aladdin!!
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

Yes, I'm referring to the "magic cotton" metal cleaner... Well, after my experience I should say that sometimes cleans and some others gets dirty...

I was so excited to show my Agfa Silette I from 1953 to you, colleagues. And when I was taking some pictures I noticed a small area a little matte.

The cam was mint as new:



So I took Aladdin and started to clean the top area. It got shining, so I proceeded with the front pannel.

And then the disaster... Every area touched by the Aladdin, got an orangeish tone. No way of taking it out!.



So be careful and learn from my experience. Try first a hidden area prior to use Aladdin...

Jes.


Reply

I feel sorry for you Smile

But as you have seen, the quality of the chrome on Agfa cameras shows a lot of variation. Some parts are virtually indestructible, while other parts lose their finish just by looking at them. Another example are the Agfa Silette folders: the knobs on top of the camera are VERY thinly plated. These wear out quite fast.


Reply

Spotmatic escribió:
I feel sorry for you Smile

But as you have seen, the quality of the chrome on Agfa cameras shows a lot of variation. Some parts are virtually indestructible, while other parts lose their finish just by looking at them. Another example are the Agfa Silette folders: the knobs on top of the camera are VERY thinly plated. These wear out quite fast.


Thanks for your comment Smile

Do you think the problem is that the Aladdin took out the finishing?. To me seemed that it was colouring only, I really didn't put too much product on...

Regards.

Jes.


Reply

To me it looks like you wore off the silver finish.. Sad


Reply

mo escribió:
To me it looks like you wore off the silver finish.. Sad


Looks that way to me as well. Neutral Short of painting it, or having it re-plated, I'm not sure that there is much you can do at this point...


Reply

Yes, it looks just like it removed the chrome plating leaving the brass.

I have worn and damaged pieces that look just like that after cleaning.

Also plated silverware looks like that if polished too much.


Reply

Thanks colleagues, it should be as you state.

So thin is the plating of this camera?... I have a spare one, I'll have to fully disassemble it and swap the front plates Sad. Or take it to resilver...

Thanks for your help!

Regards.

Jes.


Reply

Jesito escribió:
So thin is the plating of this camera?


It is brass or something else inexpensive metal, which has been electrically coated when submerged in liquid with electrical charge and molecules (can someone help me with the English name for this industrial metal coating process?). It means the coating metal layer which gives the silver polish look is very very thin, thus sensitive to removal by silver polish and other strong chemicals.


Reply

Esox lucius escribió:
Jesito escribió:
So thin is the plating of this camera?


It is brass or something else inexpensive metal, which has been electrically coated when submerged in liquid with electrical charge and molecules (can someone help me with the English name for this industrial metal coating process?). It means the coating metal layer which gives the silver polish look is very very thin, thus sensitive to removal by silver polish and other strong chemicals.



Elecroplating, which can be done at home. With care !

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroplating

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D99qgd8XlV0

In theory, you should be able to strip the plating off the damaged part using this process, then replate it. Reverse the polarity.

I've just seen that there are brush plating kits for sale, maybe that's the answer?

http://www.gaterosplating.co.uk/The-Ultimate-Brush-Plating-Kit.php

I remember doing it as an apprentice many years ago, and it's not difficult.


Reply

Lloydy escribió:

Elecroplating, which can be done at home. With care !


It does not even need that much care - it is more basic hobbyist stuff than camera or lens repair, and you can get nicely working kits at Conrad, Radio Shack and the like. The snag however is that you will never hit the tone of the original unless you are a master with years of experience - so you'll have to disassemble, de-plate and re-plate everything.


Reply

Jes, that's a shame. I've been trying to find out what chemicals your polish contains that might discolour chrome (e.g. hydrochloric acid), but it seems to be mainly ammonia and white spirit with some volatile solvents, so I don't understand how that could have happened. Rubbing off the chrome plating does seem more likely, and plating was often very poor quality in the 50s.

Aladdin polish is called Duraglit here, and we have two versions - a gentle one for cleaning silver (Silvo) which is purely a chemical action and has an anti-tarnishing additive, and the other, more coarse, version for brass (Brasso) which contains an abrasive. I don't know if you have two versions there too, but I'm guessing the one you used is probably abrasive.


Reply

Lloydy escribió:
Esox lucius escribió:
Jesito escribió:
So thin is the plating of this camera?


It is brass or something else inexpensive metal, which has been electrically coated when submerged in liquid with electrical charge and molecules (can someone help me with the English name for this industrial metal coating process?). It means the coating metal layer which gives the silver polish look is very very thin, thus sensitive to removal by silver polish and other strong chemicals.



Elecroplating, which can be done at home. With care !

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroplating

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D99qgd8XlV0

In theory, you should be able to strip the plating off the damaged part using this process, then replate it. Reverse the polarity.

I've just seen that there are brush plating kits for sale, maybe that's the answer?

http://www.gaterosplating.co.uk/The-Ultimate-Brush-Plating-Kit.php

I remember doing it as an apprentice many years ago, and it's not difficult.


Thanks a lot Lloydy!.

I think it will be worth to try it ... Smile. I love my Silette I Sad


Reply

Sevo escribió:
Lloydy escribió:

Elecroplating, which can be done at home. With care !


It does not even need that much care - it is more basic hobbyist stuff than camera or lens repair, and you can get nicely working kits at Conrad, Radio Shack and the like. The snag however is that you will never hit the tone of the original unless you are a master with years of experience - so you'll have to disassemble, de-plate and re-plate everything.


I was about to disassemble the camera anyway, (to swap the plate with a spare one that it's not so well conserved), so I will try the plating.
The only drawback is that I will have to peel off the leatherette and I'm not sure it will support a resticking...

Thanks for the info, Sevo!.

Regards.

Jes.


Reply

peterqd escribió:
Jes, that's a shame. I've been trying to find out what chemicals your polish contains that might discolour chrome (e.g. hydrochloric acid), but it seems to be mainly ammonia and white spirit with some volatile solvents, so I don't understand how that could have happened. Rubbing off the chrome plating does seem more likely, and plating was often very poor quality in the 50s.

Aladdin polish is called Duraglit here, and we have two versions - a gentle one for cleaning silver (Silvo) which is purely a chemical action and has an anti-tarnishing additive, and the other, more coarse, version for brass (Brasso) which contains an abrasive. I don't know if you have two versions there too, but I'm guessing the one you used is probably abrasive.


You're right, Peter. Yes, there are also two versions here, one for silver as well, (I can't recall the local name). But I bought and used the stronger one, as you suspected Sad. It worled fine for many cameras in the past, until this.

I'm afraid the only way out is to disassemble the cam, take out the plate and to try to resilver it. I'll be investigating this because some other cams have lost the plating and could be a nice revival for them, to be shining back.

For the cams that have lost the black painting, I did try to paint them with the help of an airbrush and dilluted Tamiya paint, with some success. But never had any problem of such strong effect on silvered ones, always they got back shining...

That's what I call "learning by experience"... Wink

Thanks for your help.

Regards.

Jes.


Reply

Jesito escribió:
I was about to disassemble the camera anyway, (to swap the plate with a spare one that it's not so well conserved), so I will try the plating.


Please report back with your results when you do!


Reply

Scheimpflug escribió:
Jesito escribió:
I was about to disassemble the camera anyway, (to swap the plate with a spare one that it's not so well conserved), so I will try the plating.


Please report back with your results when you do!


Of course I'll do. Wink

It's in the queue after the fix for the Praktica FX3 ...

Regards,

Jes.


Reply

An idea has flashed in my mind:

Does anybody have experience with "Bare metal" adhesive foils?. They are used to "metalize" plastic models of cars, airplanes, etc...
Thinking of using it to cover the damaged part, but not sure if the final result would be acceptable.

Regards.

Jes.