MFlenses - Una nueva vida en la era digital
MFLenses 2026

Foro de objetivos de enfoque manual

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.

Explora el mundo de los objetivos antiguos mediante notas de reparación, pruebas reales e hilos de archivo llenos de imágenes.
Destacado

Espacio de socio destacado en la portada del foro.

Which polarizer
Ver tema anterior :: Ver tema siguiente  


Reply

I want to buy some polarizers for few uses to come.

I am looking on eBay and found some for few euros (6e), brand ones are more expensives (70e).

I need one for my sigma EX 10-20mm diameter 77mm
and another one for my Canon EF L 70-200 diam 62

Don't want to buy expensive brand CPL, but don't want to buy some "SH*Ts" too.

Do you have any advices ?

thanks


Reply

I have same requirement than you have pretty good one for reasonable price. Try to get used B+W with scratch for example. It will be cheap I guess. I did try B+W due I got in 55mm filter size very cheap. I think perfect. I also did try used PL filters Vivitar and a noname Vivitar branded perform pretty well also. Nonane Korean made was sh* I did throw out.


Reply

Nelson escribió:
I want to buy some polarizers for few uses to come.

I am looking on eBay and found some for few euros (6e), brand ones are more expensives (70e).

I need one for my sigma EX 10-20mm diameter 77mm
and another one for my Canon EF L 70-200 diam 62

Don't want to buy expensive brand CPL, but don't want to buy some "SH*Ts" too.

Do you have any advices ?

thanks


Perhaps you need for the 10-20mm Sigma lens a filter in slim-line version. This increases the prices dramatically.

Wink


Reply

EF 70-200 F4 L is 67mm.

Using thick CPL with your super-wide may gives you dark corners on the photos.


Reply

I always use decent filters as the quality of the image is dependent on the weakest link in the chain. No point in using expensive glass if you put a cheap filter in front of it IMO.


Reply

martinsmith99 escribió:
I always use decent filters as the quality of the image is dependent on the weakest link in the chain. No point in using expensive glass if you put a cheap filter in front of it IMO.


+1


Reply

The cheap polarizers are piece of crap.

If you don't need AF and autoexposure, you might consider linear polarizers instead of circular.

Here is a good review with lots of insight: http://www.lenstip.com/115.1-article-Polarizing_filters_test.html


Reply

Attila escribió:
martinsmith99 escribió:
I always use decent filters as the quality of the image is dependent on the weakest link in the chain. No point in using expensive glass if you put a cheap filter in front of it IMO.


+1


+1

A B+W 77mm polarizer can be found at about 150US$. As alternative, you could check the Hoya Pro 1, at about half the price ...

Personally, i prefer the B+W, but my lenses have smaller filter threads (49 and 52mm) Wink ...

Cheers


Reply

Anu escribió:
The cheap polarizers are piece of crap.

If you don't need AF and autoexposure, you might consider linear polarizers instead of circular.

Here is a good review with lots of insight: http://www.lenstip.com/115.1-article-Polarizing_filters_test.html


This is an excellent idea.


Reply

Go for this one:
http://www.7dayshop.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=5975

Go store, plus the review seems to use the same Sigma and had no compaints.


Reply

martinsmith99 escribió:
I always use decent filters as the quality of the image is dependent on the weakest link in the chain. No point in using expensive glass if you put a cheap filter in front of it IMO.


I quit never use polarizer, but for pictures of ocean it is required.


Reply

Polarizers aren't really needed on UWAs like your Sigma 10-20 (the sky for example, is saturated enough without PLs). I've read that several times on other forums and I've convinced myself into it with my Tokina 12-24. Wink


Reply

symphonic escribió:
Polarizers aren't really needed on UWAs like your Sigma 10-20 (the sky for example, is saturated enough without PLs). I've read that several times on other forums and I've convinced myself into it with my Tokina 12-24. Wink

Totally agree!
bb2


Reply

indianadinos escribió:
Attila escribió:
martinsmith99 escribió:
I always use decent filters as the quality of the image is dependent on the weakest link in the chain. No point in using expensive glass if you put a cheap filter in front of it IMO.
+1
+1

+1 more. Except in my case, it isn't that I always use decent filters... it's that I sometimes use my mid-grade filters and wish I had spent a little more on higher quality versions. Wink


symphonic escribió:
Polarizers aren't really needed on UWAs like your Sigma 10-20 (the sky for example, is saturated enough without PLs). I've read that several times on other forums and I've convinced myself into it with my Tokina 12-24. Wink

Skies are not the only reason to use a polarizer. Removing reflections is an important usage, which many times cannot be accomplished any other way. Cool


Reply

Scheimpflug escribió:

Skies are not the only reason to use a polarizer. Removing reflections is an important usage, which many times cannot be accomplished any other way. Cool


Yes, you're right. I haven't thought of that. Smile


Reply

indianadinos escribió:


+1

A B+W 77mm polarizer can be found at about 150US$. As alternative, you could check the Hoya Pro 1, at about half the price ...

Personally, i prefer the B+W, but my lenses have smaller filter threads (49 and 52mm) Wink ...
Cheers

Yes, I use these 2 makes. I think B&W are easier to clean so I have switched to them. Plus they make smaller filters which, as you say, is good when you want 49mm.


Reply

In my opinion Kenko Pro1D series is by far the best value CPL; I have different filters of various brands, and I don't think it needs to be ashamed next to B+W or Heliopan.


Reply

As i needed polarizer for few photos, i decided to buy cheap ones (ie not 80e ones....)
i bought two on ebay for 10e each (polarizer + uv filter)

i received two polarizers 67mm+77mm branded Kenko !!!

Lets see if they are good or bad


Reply

Nelson escribió:

i received two polarizers 67mm+77mm branded Kenko !!!

Lets see if they are good or bad


Note that Kenko (and most other manufacturers) have several “lines” of polarizers; the Pro1D series is the “good stuff”, the cheaper ones are pretty generic. But hopefully they will do the trick! =)


Reply

Anyone have some sample shots with a good and a bad pol filter, just for curiosity and future reference?


Reply

martinsmith99 escribió:
I always use decent filters as the quality of the image is dependent on the weakest link in the chain. No point in using expensive glass if you put a cheap filter in front of it IMO.


+ infinity Very Happy

I use high end B&W CPL filtres. Why spend $1000 on a lense and put crap glass in front of it?


Reply

I stumbled across Marumi DHG polarizers a while ago. Compared to my way more expensive Kenko/Hoya Pro 1D, I cannot see a difference in performance.

According to this test (http://www.lenstip.com/115.4-article-Polarizing_filters_test_Results_and_summary.html), they even smoke some of the B+W which are several times more expensive.

Another big plus for me is that they are slim filters but, in contrast to the B+W, also have a front thread so I can screw a lens hood on top.


Reply

I did try Massa UV filter what is cheap like chips and works perfect , invisible on pictures.